Back to Index

Study Finds Expanded EITC Can Boost Housing Security For Childless Adults

New research shows a temporary expansion to the Earned Income Tax Credit improved housing security for young workers who don't have children. The findings – from researchers at Columbia University and the University of Michigan – have implications for federal and state policymakers looking to reduce hardship for childless workers ages 19 to 24. Spotlight spoke with one of the study’s authors, Natasha Pilkauskas, associate director of Poverty Solutions at the University of Michigan, about the research. Pilkauskas, who also is a public policy professor, co-authored the journal article and policy brief with Jiwan Lee, a postdoctoral research associate at Brown University's Population Studies and Training Center; Katherine Michelmore, a public policy professor at the Gerald R. Ford School of Public Policy at U-M; and Christopher Wimer, a senior research scientist and director of the Center on Poverty and Social Policy at Columbia University. The interview with Pilkauskas has been edited for length and clarity.

Why don’t we start with a quick explanation of what the Earned Income Tax Credit is, and we can go from there.

Natasha Pilkauskas, associate director of Poverty Solutions at the University of Michigan,

‍Pilkauskas: The Earned Income Tax Credit is a refundable tax credit for low-income families and usually most of our Earned Income Tax Credit is paid to families with children. Depending on the number of kids you have, you get a bigger credit. And we have a much smaller, refundable credit for folks who don't have children. So typically, the average maximum credit you can get for the Earned Income Tax credit if you were childless—and to be clear, that means you don't have a child that you can claim on your taxes—is relatively small. It's only about $500, as compared to the one for families with children, where the average is closer to $2,000 to $3,000 depending on how many kids you have.

And that childless group, the 18 to 24 group that you focus on, historically has been very high poverty, correct?

Yes. They're very high poverty and they are currently excluded from the childless EITC; you can claim it if you’re over the age of 25. But in this study, we looked at this expansion of the childless EITC that happened in 2021 under the American Rescue Plan Act.

‍Why don't you tell us a little bit more about the impact those changes had.

They did two things that were sort of important, at least for our study. They reduced the age that you could claim it to from 25 to 19, so we could look at these young adults who are quite high poverty. And they also tripled the amount of the credit, from about $500 to close to $1,500.

So, clearing that background out of the way, let’s talk about what you did in this study. You looked at the impact of the expanded EITC on this group in terms of several types of material hardship?

Exactly. We look at housing hardships or the ability to pay your rent. We look at your ability to pay your bills and as well as food hardship or food insufficiency.

And what were some of the high points of what you found?

What we find is that the expansion of this credit for this population, in particular for folks with incomes under $25,000 a year, brought a reduction in their housing hardship. We find it's three percentage points, but that's actually almost a 29% reduction in the reports of people saying that they were having this challenge, which is a pretty big effect. And for both ability to pay your bills and your food, we find a reduction but not a statistically significant effect, but we do find a reduction. We like to think of this as suggestive evidence, rather than concrete evidence. It's suggesting that it helped people make ends meet, essentially.

And do you worry at all that given all the pandemic aid that was flowing at that time, that respondents are able to sift between them and focus on what the EITC brought them?

We're using data that is very high frequency over time, so we can actually pinpoint to a very specific time window. We're interviewing people right around the time that they're receiving these credits, and that's where we see it. To people who were claiming their taxes in the spring of 2022, there were fewer emergency programs going on.

There was an unsuccessful effort to extend the expanded Child Tax Credit. Have there been similar efforts with the expanded EITC?

Kamala Harris proposed reinstating the credit during her presidential campaign, in terms of both increasing the amount and allowing younger folks to claim it. I don't actually really know why we have this limit of being 25, given that a lot of people are independent at earlier ages. Some states have a childless EITC that goes down to 18 actually and a few states have actually decided to retain the credit, Some already had it before this was put in place, and some have retained the COVID-era expansion.

Thirty-one states provide childless EITC and they typically mirror the federal policy, though they vary wildly in how generous they are. Thirty-one have a childless EITC, and then California, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, and New Jersey, allow folks who are under 25 to claim it. Colorado and New Mexico actually added that age group after the expansion and made it permanent. I think in many ways, this is quite popular across that political aisle because these are folks who can't claim the EITC if they aren't working.

I have other work also that has found the EITC helps with housing outcomes. We see people are less likely to be housing burdened—they're less likely to be doubling up. We find the same thing with some work that I do on the Child Tax Credit, actually, which sort of points to the benefits of giving people some cash. And I do think that in some ways, the lump sum nature of the EITC, the fact that you kind of get a big chunk of change, can really help with housing as it can be used for a down payment or paying back rent.